Traditional New York Cookies, stamped with historic Rooster and Kitty stamps.
I spent last Sunday morning at Old Stone House, stamping out cookies with the local kids of Park Slope. Â The stamps are historic replicas from House on the Hill and are just. beautiful. Â I was shocked at the level of detail the molds yielded; although I used them with 19th century cookie recipes, I think they would work well with most modern sugar cookie dough.
Stamped cookies are a tradition early Dutch settlers brought to New York (nee New Amsterdam).  Over the years, they became known as a New York tradition that transcended immigrant groups.  In the city, stamped cakes were passed out as treats on New Year’s Day, and as a memorial token at funerals.
Heating up the hearth at Old Stone House. Â I lit a large fire and let it burn down to red and white hot coals. Â Then, I pushed the coals to the back of the oven, and placed the cookies in the front. Â To test the oven, I made Tollhouse break and bake cookies, and they baked exactly as long as they said they would on the package. Â Voila!
A teeny helper dusts confectionar’s sugar in the mold. Â The sugar stops the dough from sticking, and delivers a more detailed image. Â Photo by Sharon Stadul
And then we stamp. Â Photo by Sharon Stadul.
We made two cookie recipes on Sunday: one, a caraway and orange cookie, came from the book Food, Drink and Celebrations of the Hudson Valley Dutch by Peter G. Rose.  Man they were good – I want to experiment more with that recipe.  The second cookie was a nutmeg-cinnamon-rosewater cake called, appropriately, New York Cookies.  The recipes is from 1840 and I give it a B+.  You may like them, particularly with a cup of tea, but they taste too much like the 19th century for my liking.
***
New York Cookies
From Directions For Cookery, In Its Various Branches by Eliza Leslie, 1840.
1/2 pound sugar
2 ounces rosewater
3 pounds flour
1 nutmeg
1 tsp cinnamon
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 pound butter
***